Whakapapa Stories

The Girl on Tiree

My brother said in his post that I turned something up this week and that he would let me tell you myself.

Here it is.

If you read Joe's story, you will remember it ends on a question. Joe is at a camp in England in 1918, his best mate takes him home on leave to a Scottish island, and the mate's sister shows him round the old churches and takes him to the Saturday dance.

And then Joe writes this, fifty odd years later, as an old man.

"I really enjoyed my stay on Tiree and have often wondered what happened to Mary."

Mum says that when he was about eighty he asked one of his daughters if she could try and find her.

Nobody ever did.

That is her grandfather. He wanted to know, he asked out loud, and he died in 1978 without an answer.

So on Sunday night at half past eleven I said right, let us go and find Mary.

How I actually did this, because people ask me

I am a painter. Twenty five years up the side of buildings. I am not a historian.

What I have got is AI, and I have spent a long time learning to use it properly rather than as a toy. And the honest version is this. It is not a magic answer machine. It is more like having a crew. You have to know what to send them after. And you have to check every single thing they bring back, because a machine will hand you something wrong with exactly the same confidence it hands you something true.

That checking part is the whole job. It is most of what I do.

So on Sunday night I set it going. Not one search. Six at once, pointed in different directions. Then a second lot whose only job was to try and knock down whatever the first lot found.

Then I went to bed.

The wall

Here is what came back, and it stopped everything.

There was no McKay sheep farming family on Tiree.

Every census the island has, 1841 through 1921, went through line by line. Every recorded gravestone. The island's own archive. There were McKays on Tiree, but not one of them fits. The Free Church minister's family at Scarinish, who had two sons and no daughter and were gone by the end of the war. A crofter back in 1841. A post runner in 1921. That is it.

No sheep farm. No daughter Mary of the right age. Nothing.

I sat there Monday morning thinking, well, the old man got the name wrong and that is the end of it.

Except.

He told us

Go back and read what Joe actually wrote.

"We all knew him as Mack McKay although I suppose he had another name."

He told us.

He sat down to write his life out, got to his best mate, and put a hand up right there on the page to say do not trust this bit, that is only what we called him.

That sentence has been sitting in the book for fifty years and nobody read it as an instruction. I did not either. I read it as an old man being vague.

He was not being vague. He was being careful. He would not state a name he was not sure of, so he flagged it. That is the same man who stopped an interviewer mid story to put two dead men back in the right seats of a boat.

He told us how to solve it and we did not listen for half a century.

So we stopped looking for a name and went looking for a bed

Joe wrote that Mack was the fellow in the next bed. So find every Tiree man who wore a New Zealand or Australian uniform, pull his service file, and see which one of them was lying next to Joe Timms.

The island's own war roll lists them. There are not many.

Hector MacDonald of Balephuil, Otago Regiment, Military Medal in 1917. In the field the whole time, not one hospital admission on his file. Out.

John McLean of Ruaig. Killed at Gallipoli in 1915, two years before Joe reached England. Out.

Donald MacPhail of Balephuil. Died of wounds in 1917. Out.

Campbell of Cornaigmore, Mackinnon of Manal, MacLean of Cornaig, all in Australian uniform, none of them where a New Zealander lay. Out.

Dugald McDonald of Kilmoluaig had me going for hours. Tiree born, a crofter, next of kin his brother Neil on the island, and his own mother was called Mary. He walked the exact same road as Joe. Same convalescent hospital. Same fortnight of leave. Same command depot at Codford.

Three months ahead of him at every single step.

They never once overlapped.

And then a file came up for a man called Donald MacGibbon.

Four days

Private, service number 6/2216.

Second Battalion, Canterbury Infantry Regiment.

That is Joe's own battalion.

His casualty form says he was admitted to No. 2 New Zealand General Hospital at Walton on Thames on the 26th of August 1917.

Joe Timms was admitted to that same hospital on the 30th.

Four days.

And Donald did not leave. That November they kept him on there on the hospital's own strength, and he was still at Walton the following August. Joe's own medical board later put his stay there at 252 days.

So they were in that place together for the whole of it, and for the first eleven weeks of it, from the end of August to the middle of November 1917, both of them were in beds.

A whaler off Arapawa with shrapnel in him. A seaman out of Glasgow, raised on Tiree, with a back that finished him as a soldier. Same regiment. Same hospital. Four days apart.

That is the next bed.

Two lines on two army forms

This is the part that got me, and it is not in either man's own words. It is just what is written in the paperwork, side by side.

When Joe Timms enlisted, the army asked him for his next of kin. He gave them Mrs H. Godfrey of Auckland Street, Picton. And in the space for the relationship, one word.

Friend.

He had nobody else to put. He was raised by the Godfreys from the age of five and he counted them as family, he says so himself, plainly, and he never once wrote about it as hardship. But the form has a box for a relative and he did not have one to give it.

When Donald MacGibbon enlisted, the army asked him the same question. His answer is the only relative named anywhere in his entire file.

Mary MacGibbon. Sister. Tiree, Argyllshire, Scotland.

The printed roll spells it out further. Miss Mary McGibbon.

Two men in beds beside each other on the wrong side of the world. Between the pair of them, one friend and one sister.

And when the leave came through, one of them had a home to go to.

Joe's papers date it exactly. Discharged from the convalescent hospital on the 24th of June 1918. Did not report at Codford until the 9th of July. A fortnight, unaccounted for by the army, which is exactly the two weeks he wrote about.

Donald MacGibbon took Joe Timms home. Joe had nowhere else to be.

Her family, and what we can and cannot prove

Here I have to be careful, because there are three women in this and they are easy to mix up.

We have never found a document that names Donald's mother. Not one. What we have is a pattern, and I will show you it and let you judge it.

In the 1871 census there is a woman called Marion MacNeill at her father's house at Barrapol. She is twenty five, she is married, she is working as a dressmaker, and there is a baby boy in the house. The man doing the writing that day put the child's surname down as Gebbon.

One slip of a pen. That single misspelling is why every search anybody ever ran for Gibbon walked straight past this family.

Ten years later that same boy is back at the same house with the name spelled properly, McGibbon, along with two more of them, all born in Glasgow, all listed as grandchildren of the old fisherman. And in that same year the only Tiree born McGibbon woman anywhere in Britain is a Marion McGibbon, thirty five, a wife at an address in Dunbartonshire, with two of her McNeill brothers lodging under the same roof.

That is a Tiree family with their children boarded back home with their grandparents while the parents worked on the mainland. It was the ordinary way of it.

So I think Marion MacNeill is Mary's mother. I think it strongly. I have not proved it, and until I have I am going to keep saying I think.

There is even a wobble inside it. In 1871 that baby is written down as a nephew. In 1881 the same child is written down as a grandson. One of those two men got it wrong and I do not yet know which.

The other trap is this. Marion had a younger sister who was also called Mary, born about 1859. Two different daughters, two different names, one house. So Marion and Mary are not the same woman and not the same name, whatever anybody tells you.

The Mary we are after is neither of those. She is the next generation down, and three army forms call her Donald's sister, and the printed roll calls her Miss.

Her brothers and sisters, as best we can put them in order: John, born about 1870. Hugh, born at Cadder in 1871, who went to Canada and worked as a baker. Maggie. Catherine. Donald, born in Glasgow on New Year's Day 1884, our Mack. And Mary.

Four MacGibbon men off that one township went to that war.

What was coming

There is a stone in the old graveyard at Soroby on Tiree. It is the MacArthur family stone from Balephuil, and among the children listed on it is this.

EUPHEMIA, WIFE OF HUGH Mc.GIBBON, DIED AT ONTARIO CANADA, OCT 1918, AGED 41

Hugh went to Canada and married a Tiree girl from the next township along. And in October 1918 the influenza took her, and it took him. His Canadian records and his grave give the 16th of October 1918 at Hamilton, Ontario. The island's own war roll prints 1919. I am going with the Canadian records and I am telling you the roll disagrees.

Joe was in that family's house in the early part of July 1918.

By the end of October, Mary's brother and his wife were both dead on the other side of the Atlantic.

What we have not got

I am not going to finish by pretending we found her, because we have not.

We do not have Mary's own birth record. We do not know if she married. We do not know what name she died under or where she is buried.

She is not in a single Tiree census, ever. Her brother gave Tiree as her address in February 1915, and Joe was there in 1918, but she was not in her grandparents' house on any census night we can check.

There is one search left that would likely finish it. Scotland has indexed its births by the mother's maiden name since the register began. One query, McGibbon births with a MacNeill mother, should bring the whole family up in a single list with Mary's date of birth on it.

That is next.

Why I bothered

Mum's grandfather asked a question out loud when he was about eighty and nobody ever answered it.

He died in 1978 not knowing the man's real name, not knowing the girl's surname, and not knowing what became of her.

We know two of those three now.

His mate was Donald MacGibbon of Barrapol, and it was Donald who took him home. And the girl who walked him round the old churches was Mary MacGibbon, and her people were the MacNeills of Barrapol on the west end of Tiree. Her mother, I believe though I cannot yet prove it, was Marion MacNeill.

Same as everything else in this family, most of what made it possible came from Mum. She is the one who kept the papers. She is the one who told me the Mary line was in there before I had ever seen the page.

And Joe is the reason any of it could be done at all, because he wrote his own life out in his own words and flagged the bit he was not sure of.

We are not finished yet, Joe. But we know her name.

Mary MacGibbon of Barrapol, Isle of Tiree.

Sister of Donald. Almost certainly daughter of Marion.

If anybody out there knows the MacGibbons of Barrapol, or the MacNeill family of The Land, or has a Tiree connection and a long memory, we would like to hear from you. Same as always. Correct us, add to it, tell us what we have got sideways.

Anthony

◆

Original publication and source context

Original Facebook publication:
https://www.facebook.com/61583688397287/posts/pfbid02LVRSni7Mssp7TrRb5yZeCCe7FC5Zgs3WNnC1NjSL8VGxgYzSZSNphr4APtEXfmzwl/