Whakapapa Stories

The Old Whaler and the Bishop

In July 1898 an old whaler at Ocean Bay wrote to the paper to put a story about Kāpiti Island right. A bishop had already done the same, five weeks before him.

THE OLD WHALER AND THE BISHOP

He was Mr Aldridge senior, the veteran whaler who met Holiday-Seeker's party at the Ocean Bay landing that Christmas, in my last story.

On 5 July 1898, the Pelorus Guardian printed his letter, headed "Early Days at Kapiti". It was signed "M. Aldridge, Sen., Ocean Bay".

He was writing, he said, "to contradict certain statements that have crept into several colonial newspapers". He wrote that he had come to New Zealand in 1838 in the American whaling ship Vermont, and had anchored in Port Underwood in May of that year. "The Port has been my home ever since." In the early days, he wrote, he often took his whaleboat across to the Wellington shores.

The statements had begun with a death. In May 1898 a woman died at Palmerston North, and a paragraph about her, credited to the Palmerston Times, ran in at least eleven papers from Auckland to Dunedin.

The paragraph said Mrs E. Brooke had come out to New Plymouth on the Amelia Thompson in 1841, when she was about thirteen. It said that in the forties she walked from Taranaki to Wellington and back, "the only road being the sea-beach". After her marriage, it said, she lived "from about 1848" on Kāpiti Island, "then the resort of whalers". Then it said she had seen war there, and cannibalism. Those were the paper's words, printed after she died.

On 30 May, the Evening Post printed a reply headed "The Past of Kapiti". It was signed by O. Hadfield, Bishop, from Marton.

Octavius Hadfield had been a missionary on the Kāpiti coast. The Dictionary of New Zealand Biography says he became the first priest ordained in New Zealand in January 1839. That November he began his work at Waikanae and Ōtaki. Te Rauparaha, it says, became his firm friend. He was Anglican primate of New Zealand from 1890 until he retired in 1893.

In his letter he wrote that he came to Waikanae in 1839, lived there several years and visited Kāpiti "usually about once a week". "I have no hesitation in saying that since 1839 there never was any war there, or any blood shed there in fighting." Perhaps, he suggested, she had heard "from some old whaler stories of what had occurred 20 years before".

Five weeks later it was an old whaler who answered, from the other side of Cook Strait.

There were no such wars on Kāpiti in 1848, Aldridge wrote, and since 1839 there had been "no war or bloodshed caused through fighting". The other practice the paragraph named was by 1848, he wrote, "a thing of the past". One explanation he offered was that her stories had been "much exaggerated since she passed away".

Neither man said he was on Kāpiti in 1848. Hadfield's biography in the Dictionary says a serious illness confined him to a Wellington magistrate's home for almost five years from late 1844. Aldridge rested his denial on those whaleboat crossings in the early days.

Both men drew the line at 1839. For Hadfield it was the year he came to Waikanae. Aldridge did not say why he chose it.

Waitohi, sister of Te Rauparaha and mother of Te Rangihaeata, died that year. The Dictionary says ill feeling between Te Ātiawa and Ngāti Raukawa, "aroused by disputes over land", came to a head at her funeral on Mana Island. Ātiawa ki Whakarongotai's own account tells it differently. It says unresolved issues from the earlier Haowhenua conflict came to a head during her funeral, "as insults and disparaging remarks were made between the leaders".

Both accounts have fighting at Waikanae that October. The Dictionary dates the battle at Te Kūititanga to 16 October and calls it "the last conflict in arms between the tribes on this coast".

Hadfield's diary has him on Kāpiti on 21 November 1839, at a whaling station. Several of the men there, their foreman at their head, "treated us with great insolence". Another party he visited, he wrote, were "civil and well behaved". The next day he crossed to Waikanae and walked over the ground "where the late battle took place".

Nearly sixty years after that, the bishop and the old whaler were on the same side.

Hadfield ended his letter with a worry. "I am afraid that the future historian of New Zealand will find it very difficult to eliminate the true from the false".

Aldridge ended his with a promise. He would deal with the wars and other events since his arrival "truthfully in a report" for the Guardian, "at an early date". But he "could not allow such statements as those I have referred to go until then unanswered". I have not found that report in the Guardian.

That Christmas, when Holiday-Seeker's party came in by boat, the old whaler was at the landing to meet them. There were handshakes all round.

Michael Aldridge is one of ours, by marriage. The Aldridges married into Mum's side of the family, and the name still runs through our line.

This story follows the two 1898 letters as printed, and quotations keep their spelling. Her name is printed Brooke, Brooks and Brookes in different places. Aldridge's year of arrival is his own account. The pictures are separately dated, and none is known to be a picture of 1839, 1848 or 1898.

If you have ever come across the report Michael Aldridge promised the Pelorus Guardian in July 1898, I would be glad to hear where you found it.

Sources are in the comments.

◆

Sources from the original post

SOURCES AND FURTHER READING

1. Read the old whaler's letter
"Early Days at Kapiti", Pelorus Guardian and Miners' Advocate, 5 July 1898, page 2. The 1906 Cyclopedia of New Zealand, linked in the last story, names him as Michael Aldridge of Ocean Bay.
https://paperspast.natlib.govt.nz/newspapers/PGAMA18980705.2.6.2

2. Read the bishop's letter
"The Past of Kapiti", Evening Post, 30 May 1898. The letter is dated Marton, 25 May.
https://paperspast.natlib.govt.nz/newspapers/EP18980530.2.10

3. The paragraph that started it
Evening Post, 21 May 1898, the issue Hadfield answered, crediting the Palmerston Times. It carries claims this story does not repeat.
https://paperspast.natlib.govt.nz/newspapers/EP18980521.2.19

4. The Christmas visit in the last story
"Christmas at Ocean Bay", by Holiday-Seeker, Pelorus Guardian and Miners' Advocate, 27 January 1899, page 2. It calls him "the veteran whaler, and pioneer of Port Underwood".
https://paperspast.natlib.govt.nz/newspapers/PGAMA18990127.2.10

5. Octavius Hadfield
June Starke's entry in the Dictionary of New Zealand Biography, on Te Ara, including the illness that kept him in Wellington from late 1844.
https://teara.govt.nz/en/biographies/1h2/hadfield-octavius

6. Hadfield's diary, November 1839
Extracts printed in Barbara Macmorran, Octavius Hadfield (Wellington, 1969). His entries for 21 and 22 November.
https://nzetc.victoria.ac.nz/tm/scholarly/tei-MacOcta-t1-body1-d18-d4.html

7. Waitohi and 1839
Teremoana Sparks and W. H. Oliver's entry in the Dictionary of New Zealand Biography, with her death, her funeral on Mana Island and the battle at Te Kūititanga.
https://teara.govt.nz/en/biographies/1w3/waitohi

8. Te Kuititanga 1839, as Ātiawa ki Whakarongotai tell it
Their own account, in more detail than this story gives. I have set it beside the Dictionary's and have not chosen between them.
https://teatiawakikapiti.co.nz/te-kuititanga/