Near the end of the last story I wrote a sentence I thought was finished. "Anne was a daughter of William Keenan and Hika Mapu."
The same afternoon, a reader put me right. Her name was Hikimapu.
The reader was right. The Te Ātiawa pānui writes it Hikimapu, and our own family papers carry it more than one way. Her correction also sent me back into the records with a better question. Not just whose mother was she. Who was she?
This is the fourth story in the Norton and Keenan run. The first followed James Norton to the telegram at Dunedin. The second followed his brother Thomas William to Kekerengu. The third found William Henry Keenan's name beside James's at an 1853 baptism. This one belongs to Anne's mother.
On 28 September 1880, an old whaler named William Keenan died at Te Awaiti.
When the registrar reached the space on his death certificate for his wife, he wrote two words.
"A maori."
Some of you may have seen that line before. It is hard to forget. And it is the only thing that certificate says about her.
That woman was Hikimapu. William had married her twice, once in the Catholic Church and once in the Anglican. She had been baptised Katarina. She was the mother of his children, among them William Henry and Anne Elizabeth.
For her own story, you have to go to a different book.
In 1899, about four years after she died, the Māori Land Court heard evidence on an application for probate of her will. Two people were sworn, and they did not agree.
Those opposing the will said she was deaf and partly blind. Ani said she could understand English but could not reply in it.
There were two wills, dated May 1894 and 28 May 1895. The witnesses disagreed over how her mark was made.
She died at Te Awaiti in 1895, probably on 5 June, though two witnesses remembered July. Her daughters Ani Norton and Arihia Thoms were at Te Awaiti, and Ani said the houses were not far apart.
That hearing ended in an adjournment. Later witnesses said probate was refused, and in 1903 and 1904 the court made succession orders for particular blocks, in favour of her children and their descendants.
The hearing was on Friday 5 May 1899, and its record fills the court's minute book from page 161 to page 176.
So here is what the record holds. In 1880 a government form gave her two words. In 1899 a court gave her sixteen pages, under her own name, and all seven of her children are named there.
Two words on a form. Sixteen pages in a court book. And one photograph: an elderly woman sitting in the front row on the beach at Te Awaiti, walking stick in hand, with Norton and Toms family around her. The National Library names her as Katarina Hikimapu. You can see it on the National Library's website.
Sometimes, to find out who someone was, you have to go past the first record and find the second.
A note for anyone searching. If a record gives you "a maori", "native woman" or no name at all for a woman in your family, please do not stop there. That gap usually belongs to the clerk, not to her. Look for the other papers. Church registers, where she may appear under a baptismal name, the way Hikimapu was baptised Katarina. Wills and probate files. Māori Land Court minute books, where women's names, lands and families are often written down in full. Death registrations as old as William's can be searched and ordered through Births, Deaths and Marriages.
Our own line comes through Thomas William Norton, James's brother. Hikimapu is not our direct ancestor. She belongs to our wider whanaungatanga through Anne's marriage to James, and her own descendants include the Keenan, Norton and Thoms whānau. I share her story with respect, and I would be glad to be corrected by her own people.
What we do not know: the year she was born, and how the probate finally ended. I have now read the sixteen pages, but not the wills themselves.
If your whānau descends from Hikimapu and William Keenan, or holds anything on her will or the 1899 hearing, I would love to hear from you.
◆